New York Pumpernickel Bagels, 2 Dozen, Fresh Hand-Rolled NYC Bagels

New York Pumpernickel Bagels — 2 Dozen, Fresh & Hand-Rolled

Dark, earthy, and deeply satisfying — Pumpernickel bagels are a New York classic for a reason. Our hand-rolled NYC Pumpernickel bagels have that signature dense chew and rich, slightly malty flavor that pairs beautifully with just about any topping. Salmon and cream cheese? A natural. Pimento spread? Unexpectedly perfect. Butter and a cup of coffee? Hard to beat. Two dozen fresh bagels, shipped free in 2 days.

What's Included

• 24 fresh, hand-rolled extra-large NYC Pumpernickel bagels
• Free 2-day shipping — arrives fresh, ready to enjoy

Why New Yorker Bagels

• Hand-Rolled & Boiled: Traditional NYC method for authentic chew and crust
• Shipped Fresh: No preservatives of any kind — what you get is what was just baked
• No Saturated or Trans Fat
• 100% Vegan: No animal products in any of our bagels
• Star-K, Pas Yisroel Kosher Certified
• Made in the USA

Topping Ideas

Pumpernickel's bold flavor stands up to rich, savory toppings especially well. Try smoked salmon with cream cheese and capers, pimento cheese spread, whitefish salad, or classic butter and jam. Any spread that works on a plain bagel works even better here.

Allergen Information

Contains: Wheat. While our bakery does not process milk, eggs, or tree nuts, some ingredients may come from facilities that handle these allergens.

When will my order arrive?

Orders ship the next business day. Delivery is typically 3–7 business days in the continental U.S.

How much is shipping?

Free shipping on orders over $69. Shipping for orders under $69 is calculated at checkout.

What is your return policy?

We offer a 30-day return window on eligible items. Food and supplements are never restocked—damaged or incorrect items are replaced immediately.

Do you offer a money-back guarantee?

Yes. We offer a 30-day money-back guarantee on eligible items. For food and supplements, we do not restock opened products. If your item arrives damaged, defective, or incorrect, we’ll replace it or issue a refund no questions asked.

What if my item arrives damaged?

Email info@mycozyfarm.com with a photo and we’ll take care of it quickly.

Is checkout secure?

Yes. All payments are processed securely through Shopify with SSL encryption.

What payment methods do you accept?

All major credit cards, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, and Shop Pay.

Can I cancel my order?

Orders are processed fast. Contact us within 1 hour of placing your order and we’ll do our best to help.

Need help?

Email info@mycozyfarm.com or call (305) 497-6858 (Mon–Fri, 9am–4pm EST)

We are thrilled to share with you our commitment to providing the highest quality all-natural, sustainable products.

At Cozy Farm, we understand the importance of making healthy choices, both for our bodies and for the environment. That's why we strive to provide our customers with the best possible options. Our natural food store is stocked with a wide range of products, including fresh fruits and vegetables, organic meats, dairy-free options, gluten-free products, and much more. We also carry a variety of natural snacks, organic baby food, and household items made with eco-friendly materials. We have a large selection of medical products for both professional and personal use.

We are proud to be a sustainable grocery store that is committed to protecting the environment. We carefully select our suppliers based on their dedication to sustainability, and we work with local farmers and businesses to reduce our carbon footprint. We use eco-friendly packaging materials whenever possible, and we encourage our customers to do the same.

But Cozy Farm is more than just a natural food store. We are a community hub where like-minded individuals can come together to learn about healthy eating habits and other sustainable lifestyle practices.

We are proud to be your one-stop-shop for all your healthy grocery needs. We invite you to visit us and see for yourself why Cozy Farm is the go-to all-natural food store for health-conscious individuals who care about the environment.