Sandwich Spreads: Delicious Natural Toppings for Your Favorite Sandwiches | Cozy Farm
Left Continue shopping
Your Order

You have no items in your cart

Cozy Farm Logo
FREE SHIPPING - No Minimum + Subscribe and Save

Sandwich Spreads: Delicious Natural Toppings for Your Favorite Sandwiches

Sandwich Spreads: Elevate Your Meals with Savory and Sweet Delights

Explore a World of Flavorful Choices

  • Classic Mayonnaise: A culinary staple for sandwiches, salads, and dips, providing a rich and creamy base.
  • Mustard: From zingy yellow to robust brown, mustard adds a tangy kick to enhance your spread.
  • Hummus: A protein-packed spread made from chickpeas, offering a nutty and earthy flavor profile.
  • Pesto: A vibrant green spread crafted from basil, olive oil, and pine nuts, infusing your sandwiches with an aromatic zest.
  • Cream Cheese: A versatile spread perfect for breakfast bagels, lunch sandwiches, and dessert treats, available in various flavors.

Additional Considerations for Perfect Sandwich Spreads


  • Smooth and creamy for easy spreading and a velvety mouthfeel.
  • Slightly chunky for a more rustic texture and flavorful dimension.

Flavor Combinations:

  • Sweet and savory: Combine fruit preserves with cream cheese or add honey to mustard for a unique twist.
  • Tangy and spicy: Layer mayonnaise with hot sauce or add Dijon mustard to your spread for a bold kick.

Health Benefits:

  • Choose spreads with heart-healthy oils like olive oil or avocado oil.
  • Opt for low-fat or fat-free options for a lighter sandwich experience.
Elevate your sandwiches with our exquisite collection of Sandwich Spreads. From classic favorites to innovative flavors, find the perfect spread to enhance your culinary creations. Shop Now and discover a world of savory and sweet delights!
Kewpie Mayonnaise Squeeze Tube, 12 Oz. Pack of 6 - Cozy Farm
Joyva Roasted Sesame Tahini, Pack of 12 - Rich, Creamy, 15 Oz - Cozy Farm
14 in stock
Silver Spring Sauce Horseradish - Case of 9 - 9.25 Fl Oz - Cozy Farm
Woeber's Sweet And Tangy Tartar Sauce With Sweet Pickle Relish - Case Of 6 - 10 Oz. - Cozy Farm
Sold Out
Woeber's Supreme Southwest Horseradish Sauce - Case Of 6 - 10 Oz. - Cozy Farm
Sold Out
East Wind 100% Roasted Sesame No Salt Tahini - 15 Lb - 15lb Premium Tahini by East Wind - Cozy Farm
MSRP - 1%
Once Again Sesame Tahini Organic (9lb) - Single Bulk Item - Cozy Farm
6 in stock
Sir Kensington's Classic Mayonnaise (Pack of 6) - 32 Fl Oz. - Cozy Farm
Chosen Foods 12 FL OZ Coconut Oil Mayo (Pack of 6) - Cozy Farm
13 in stock
Beano's Original Submarine Dressing, 8 Oz (Pack of 12) - Cozy Farm
Sold Out
Organic Cage-Free Egg Mayonnaise by Spectrum Naturals (Pack of 12 - 16 oz) - Cozy Farm
11 in stock
36 results